Start with use, not fixtures
The strongest argument for a conversion is simple: the tub is not used, and the shower experience in that room is poor. The strongest argument against it is equally simple: someone in the household bathes, or the home would be left with no tub at all. Everything else — glass, tile, drains — is downstream of that answer.
- Who uses this bathroom, and how, on a normal week?
- Does another bathroom in the home still have a tub?
- Is stepping over the tub wall difficult for anyone now, or likely to be?
- Is the existing shower in this bathroom actually comfortable?
What changes technically
A tub drain sits at one end of the unit and connects differently than a shower drain, which sits within a sloped pan. Even a same-footprint conversion normally involves some drain work, and how much depends on joist direction and whether there is access from below. Walls that were hidden behind a tub surround often need framing correction before tile.
| Threshold | Typical requirement | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Standard curb | Simplest; curb built and waterproofed | Most conversions |
| Low threshold | Modest structural adjustment | Easier entry without full recess |
| Curbless | Recessed or built-up floor structure | Barrier-free access and open look |
Resale considerations
A home with no bathtub anywhere can be a drawback for some buyers, particularly those with young children or a preference for bathing. If the home has multiple bathrooms, converting one tub to a shower while leaving a tub elsewhere generally avoids this concern. In a single-bathroom home, this tradeoff deserves more weight.
Glass, walls and finish decisions
- Frameless glass reads larger and is easier to keep clean but costs more than framed enclosures.
- A half-wall with glass above can suit rooms where full enclosure feels heavy.
- Niche placement should be decided before tile setting begins, not after.
- Fixed panel versus swinging door depends on the entry width available.
What to settle before demolition
- 1Confirm the drain location and whether it is moving.
- 2Choose the threshold type based on the floor structure below.
- 3Select the waterproofing system for the pan and walls.
- 4Decide on glass configuration and door swing direction.
- 5Include blocking for grab bars even if none are installed immediately.
Frequently asked questions
Sources and verification
- Manufacturer installation instructions for the specific shower pan or waterproofing system used
- International Residential Code (IRC)
- This guide is educational and reflects general construction practice. It is not a substitute for manufacturer instructions, adopted building codes, or the requirements of your local building authority. Verify anything that affects permits, code compliance or product warranties before relying on it.
Spotted something that needs correcting? Tell us through the consultation form and see our editorial policy.